Thursday, November 8, 2012

A Scandal Comes to Broadway


By Jonathan Jones
Thursday, November 8, 2012




I like this musical play - kudos to the creative team as they have taken on a tremendously difficult task - for this work will undoubtedly be compared to a slew of recent Broadway offerings, some good, and some awful.

On the surface, this musical is Leap of Faith with a woman evangelical preacher, rather than a man. Leap of Faith, however, was monumentally flawed. The music was unmemorable. The characters were all despicable. And the performances were unfortunate. In Scandalous, the music is also unmemorable - but it doesn't grate on the sense in the way that Leap of Faith's music did. Kathie Lee Gifford's strength here is the book she has carfted, for the character of Aimee Semple McPherson could easily be as despicable as those we saw in Leap, but she is shown to be flawed, but tremendously likeable. She is entirely sympathetic and we want to root for her (more on that later). And Carolee Carmello's performance is undeniably tremendous.

In moments, we see The Book of Mormon for part of Aimee Semple McPherson's oeuvre included extravagant biblical stage spectacles - and we do have a few moments of this in Act 2 - though no-where near the polish and pizzazz that is seen in Mormon.

At times, we have Chaplin, for this is a biographical musical that sings its way into your heart. You want to love Aimee. The problem is, we don't know here. In fact, I would venture to say that the average theatre goer has never heard of her. This might not be a problem (would we know Gypsy Rose Lee anymore without the musical to remind us), but here it is a problem because the work is a tough sell. It's not religious, but it is. It's called scandalous, but there is no scandal until Act 2, and even then - nothing remotely scandalous to 2012 audiences - so how do you sell the show without a name? In light of Ms. Gifford's achievement in book writing, the music is adequate - but we need to LOVE the music so we can LOVE Aimee. We want to see her explode into song that is so strong and memorable that we too will leap to our feet when she triumphs, and sob into Kleenex when she fails. But that never happens because the music isn't strong enough.

But, the music isn't bad. Like I said of Chaplin a few months ago, this work will not last long here on Broadway as there is little appetite for the conventional musical when bloated revivals of the greats are competing, but this little show should have a life in regional and community theatre where the audience may well know the actress is they don't know the character and they can laud her (whomever she might be) out of their deep love for her, if the music leaves them failing to love the character. And this is not in any way a shortcoming on the part of Ms. Carmello - she's doing the best she can with the material she's been given.

And to Ms. Gifford. She is very capable and I could not be happier. I have been a fan for twenty years, but I had my doubts as to what this would sound like. She must keep writing. Disney would do well to hire her to write music for their animated films - her charms definitely live through the lyrics. Like Queen of the Mist last year, this little show is worth seeing, but not at Broadway prices. And that's not a bad thing. We need new voices and I'm so happy that Kathie Lee Gifford has found a new way to use hers.




Scandalous is playing at The Neil Simon Theatre. Tickets can be purchased here.

Wednesday, November 7, 2012

A Dickensian Christmas at Studio54

By Jonathan Jones
Wednesday, November 7, 2012







Tickets for The Mystery of Edwin Drood is playing at Studio 54. Tickets can be purchased here.


Wednesday, October 24, 2012

Maybe...Maybe Not...

By Jonathan Jones
Wednesday, October 24, 2012

Leapin' lizards! This production of Annie is unfortunate. 

Maybe I'm too old. Or maybe it's just bad. But I can't think of a good word to say.

Well, I adore Katie Finnernan. I do not adore her in this show. But I adore Katie Finnernan. 

The dialect coach for this production should re-think career choices. The orphan girls sound British when they sing, and Lilla Crawford's shrill tone sits somewhere between Cyndi Lauper and Ellen Green's rendition of Audrey in the Orginal Off Broadway cast of Little Shop of Horrors (and the film as well). Why is this happening? Poor Miss Crawford means well, is appropriately precocious and eager, but what voodoo are they doing with her voice and why?

We get it - this desire to pretend that everyone in New York has a twisted vulger accent and have had them for the last two centuries - but we know better. In a city of immigrants, some do indeed have that harsh accent, but not everyone. We will accept it is New York because we see that it is New York (hell, they even sing the dreadful "N Y C" tune to be clear about it) - we don't need to pretend. Just let the kids sing!

And, for many in my generation who are too young to have seen the original outing on Broadway 30-some years ago but old enough to have grown up with the original film version, it is no wonder that some songs were shaved from the score for the film. "You Won't Be an Orphan for Long" "Something Was Missing" "New Deal for Christmas" - Cringeworthy!

But I'm sure the kids will like it, so by all means, bring them to the theatre. It is a holiday treat. But it's saccharine qualities will soon decay and this revival will hopefully decay along with them.



Annie is playing at The Palace Theatre. Tickets can be purchased here.

Friday, October 19, 2012

Loving Jason Tam: Marry Me a Little

By Jonathan Jones
Friday, October 19, 2012



Jason Tam first became an object of my theatrical-hero worship after his appearance in Every Little Step as he delivered his heartbreaking audition for Paul in the latest revival of A Chorus Line. Thereafter, I endured the drek of Lysistrata Jones where he emerged as one bright light. Thus, upon reading of his latest appearance in Marry Me a Little, I jumped at the opportunity to see the show.

Jason is wonderful. His costar, Lauren Molina was new too me yet she too was wonderful. This revue - ah - less so. For Sondheim lovers, I'm sure this is a dream. But for me, who is less inclined to love the sonic-chaos of Sondheim's 'smart' music, this was a jagged pill to swallow. And if there was more to hang your hat on than the music, it might not have been so jarring, but as this revue meanders from one song to the next trying desperately to weave together a tale of two unfortunate New York singles living literally on top of each other in an apartment building - yet this weave is so loose, it barely holds together at all. 

Alas, hero worship for the talents on the stage was all I had to hold onto, and I was very grateful that it only lasted 55 minutes.




Wednesday, October 17, 2012

I Hate Jonathan Franzen: House for Sale

By Jonathan Jones
Wednesday, October 17, 2012


In 2002, like many a New York commuter,  I was sucked in by my fellow strap hangers who were all carrying the same book: The Corrections. Like a fool, I followed the heard and bought the book. Page after page, I grew to hate the characters more and more. And page after page, I kind of started to hate myself for not ending the torturous read. But, given the hundreds of pages and hours of time invested, I was finishing that book no matter how much I hated it.

With that memory still fresh in my mind, when I saw the ad for Transport Theatre Group's production of House for Sale, I thought - there must be something hear. Last year, I LOVED their production of Queen of the Mist so much that I trusted their artistic choices. Alas, with Jonathan Franzen, I should know better - fool me once...

This show is basically one long verbose first-person essay delivered (for reasons I cannot comprehend) by five actors. Franzen tells about his mother's death, his detachment from his family and his mother's earthly possessions - and basically, his utter douchiness. When I crawled through The Corrections, I wanted to hate him since he created the despicable characters that inhabit his narrative - and from the way he so clearly paints their picture, I felt he surely must love them - thus, I wanted to hate him. But, I couldn't be sure how much of him was there. Now I know. And now I am sure that I hate him. He is utterly self-serving, self-congratulating, and foolish enough to disguise a story that should clearly be about his mother in a story that is him, him, him. 

In the style of the most bland and unfortunate ethnodrama, this show is a disaster. With moments of unison, overlapping dialogue, repetition, curious wall climbing, and a bizarre Minnie Mouse costume (you have to see it to believe it), this plods along in such a "CRAFTY" way that you can literally see the director's anguish as he tries so desperately to make the undramatic dramatic. The most foolish convention of all is a series of small color-coded strip lights strategically placed around the set - each actor assigned a color - and when their color lights up, they speak. And when it goes dark, they go silent. Was the stage manager telling them when to speak? Prompting them? Going insane trying to keep up? Sometimes messing up, causing ever-so-slight snickers from the cast. We had unwittingly taken a trip to the nut house - and we wanted our money back.


House for Sale is at the Duke on 42nd Street through November 18. Tickets can be purchased here.

Friday, October 12, 2012

Douglas Hodges Slays In Cyrano

By Jonathan Jones
Friday, October 12, 2012






Cyrano De Bergerac is playing at The American Airlines Theatre. Tickets can be purchased here.